Hot or iced: dietitians say both teas offer health benefits
Unsweetened iced tea can be as healthy as hot tea, say dietitians, with most of the benefits coming from the tea itself and not the temperature.
Unsweetened iced tea can be just as hydrating and healthy as hot tea, according to two registered dietitians. The main differences between the two drinks are minor, and the biggest factor for nutrition is what you add to your cup.
Hydration and antioxidants
"Iced tea can be a refreshing, hydrating beverage, especially during the warmer months," said Carlyne Remedios, a registered dietitian at JM Nutrition. Janice Chow, who runs The Mindful Chow nutrition counseling service, agreed that some people may drink more fluids if they like the cold temperature of iced tea, especially after exercise or in hot weather. The ice in the drink adds a little extra water, Chow said, but the difference is small.
Both iced and hot tea contain plant compounds called polyphenols, which are antioxidants. These have been linked to lower risks of conditions such as neurological disorders, cancer, type 2 diabetes and heart disease. Chow said, "Depending on the types of tea, it provides beneficial plant compounds such as polyphenols, which have antioxidant properties."
Hot tea's edge and comfort
Hot tea does have a slight edge in antioxidants. Remedios said the brewing temperature makes a difference because heat helps extract more antioxidants from the tea leaves. "Research has found that herbal tea brewed at higher temperatures has higher levels of antioxidants than teas brewed at lower temperatures," she said. These antioxidants include flavonoids and polyphenols.
Chow added that hot tea can also help when you're feeling under the weather. "If you have a cold or sore throat, the warmth helps loosen mucus and relieves congestion," Chow said. Many people also find hot tea comforting and relaxing, she said. It can encourage a slower, more mindful drinking experience.
Hot-brewed tea that is then chilled and served over ice won't lose most of its beneficial compounds, according to Remedios.
Sugar is the real issue
The biggest nutritional pitfall is not the brewing method, but what you add to your tea. Sugar is the main concern, said Remedios. "One tablespoon of sugar provides approximately 12 to 15 grams of carbohydrates, along with unnecessary calories with little nutritional value." Over time, too much sugar can lead to blood sugar spikes, weight gain and a higher risk of chronic diseases, potentially offsetting the benefits of drinking tea.
Both experts recommended keeping sugar to a minimum or skipping it entirely. Chow said, "The healthiest tea is usually the unsweetened tea you'll enjoy drinking regularly." Remedios suggested boosting flavor with lemon juice, orange slices, berries, cinnamon, ginger, mint or cardamom if you want variety without added sugar.
"Consider personal preferences, the weather or climate, and how likely you are to drink it regularly. Some people prefer iced tea for refreshment, while others enjoy the comfort of a warm beverage," Chow said. "Ultimately, the best choice is the one that fits your lifestyle and helps you stay hydrated consistently."